
Alumni Advice: Salary Negotiation
We asked alumni on St. Thomas Connect “What advice do you have for students or fellow alumni who have received a new job offer, and are hoping to negotiate salary or other benefits?” You can learn from these words of wisdom below!
Looking for salary data? The Labor Market Tool provides up-to-date data on employers, job titles and skills by occupation and location. The St. Thomas Career Outcomes dashboard allows you to see employment outcomes of alumni 6 months after graduation.
1.) Know your number – We all have bills to pay and financial goals, and an offer needs to support those real-world considerations.
Daniel Hildebrandt
2.) Know your flex points – Is a shorter commute or greater work-flex opportunity worth a little less on the base? Go in with clarity on where you are willing to make trade-offs that will work for you.
3.) Understand the total compensation package – Salary is one piece, but benefits play a huge role. Go in knowing where your priorities are (medical coverage, time off, education / development support, retirement support, stock ownership etc.) and look holistically at the offer on the table. And don’t get sold on bonus – a 20% annual bonus might look good on an offer letter, but what if average payout is 50% of target?
4.) Be respectful of the company’s position – Budget / internal equity considerations may not allow for base salary flexibility up front, and some policies may not allow for negotiation (e.g. – PTO). A sign-on bonus can be a good option to bridge the gap.
“When you receive an offer, the employer is at their MOST excited and they DON’T want to restart the entire search process. They are highly motivated to secure you on their staff, so feel free to shoot for the moon when it comes to compensation and other benefits.“
John Rogers
“Especially for those looking for business development positions – if you aren’t willing to negotiate on your own behalf, what would make an employer think you would negotiate on their behalf if they hire you. This is expected and part of the hiring process.“
Colleen Dolan
“Know your worth and the value of that position in your specific location & job sector. Just because the average salary in a given metro is XXXX, the industry hiring for it can significantly be impacted. Be prepared to negotiate on everything: salary, PTO, severance, wellness benefits, continued education, a one-time or annual bonus, relocation allotment, travel expenses, etc. You are in your most powerful position in your first position at the company. Make sure that you wholly lean into it.”
Sarah Halby
“Do your homework ahead of time. Look to BLS.gov and various job boards to understand what you should expect for salary ranges. Most firms slot people into salary scale that provides consistency and fairness across the company. You should be willing to make a counteroffer to see if there is any room for improvement (employers expect this). In your counteroffer, you might also seek additional PTO (days off), as it is sometimes easier for hiring managers to negotiate non-salary items. At the end of the day, if you are not thrilled with the financial package, but you want to work for the firm, request a performance and salary review in six months.
Tom Fischer
Bottom line: it’s not all about money. Make sure you are being treated fairly, but it is just as important to have a job you enjoy.“
“Always come back with a counteroffer and discuss all the entire compensation (401k, vacation, bonus/profit sharing, etc.)”
Samantha Auguin
“Don’t count on raises or bonuses. Negotiate the salary you deserve from the get-go.“
Sara Ford
“I use Salary.com and Glassdoor.com for salary information by position and location.”
Allan Hansen
“Know what people in your field with similar levels of experience are getting paid. Don’t sell yourself short. You’ve worked hard to get where you are and you deserve to be compensated fairly, even at an entry level position. If they want to start you at salary lower than you’d like (and you’re okay with it), make sure there is a plan, in writing, that outlines a timeline and amount for your next raise. Know your boundaries and what you’re willing to be flexible with (for example, maybe you’re okay with an extra week of PTO vs an extra $1000-$2000 added to your salary). And lastly, don’t be afraid to say no to a position if they’re not being straight with you about what they can provide. There will be more opportunities out there.”
Anne Michael
“Be aware of what is competitive for your position by doing your pre-game research. If you have an educational or experiential background that plays in your favor, don‘t hesitate to tactfully make this known. Try to have a good awareness of your employer‘s personal disposition. Some are more open to negotiation than others, and in certain instances, attempting to negotiate may play against you. You want to be assertive and confident but express your competency in a prudent way.”
B. Kim Dolan
“Know your value within the market- go into all negotiations knowing what you’re worth to competitors and go into with confidence.”
Elizabeth Smithley
“Know what the salary range is for the position. Now what the market range is for that job. Now what you are worth based on what you bring to the job – degree, experience etc.”
Linda Ladley
“Ask questions, about anything.”
Pat Addy
“Research salary ranges for the job. Glassdoor is a resource my office uses when hiring, I’m sure there are may others.
Consider betting on yourself at hire and propose a salary review after the first six months of employment. At that point the employer has had an opportunity to get to know you, your work and your fit to the job. If those are positive it allows the employer to frame your specific performance within the employer’s prior experience with the job.“
Daniel Schlichting
“Do your homework! Try to understand pay ranges for the position at the particular company and also within the industry. Pay attention to geographic area that the position would be located at as that can have a huge bearing as well. Last, set reasonable expectations relative to pay and be sure to evaluate salary and benefits from a total compensation perspective.“
Jim Douglas